And I’d check the network before deciding either app is broken. If the Fire Stick doesn’t appear, the checks are to restart both devices, confirm they share the same Wi-Fi rather than a guest network, and turn off the iPhone’s VPN, which can block local connections. I’d also check Settings → My Fire TV → About → Check for Updates. Installing the DoCast iPhone app won’t make those checks irrelevant.
I’d separate two approaches: put a mirroring app on the iPhone, or put an AirPlay receiver on the Fire Stick. The stated reason for needing either is that Fire TV Stick doesn’t support Apple’s AirPlay out of the box, so it won’t normally appear in the iPhone’s Screen Mirroring menu. That also means I wouldn’t interpret a missing device there as proof the hardware is faulty.
AirScreen takes the receiver route. On the Fire Stick, go to Find → Search, search for AirScreen, install it, then open it and follow the prompts. With both devices on the same Wi-Fi, the instructions say to swipe down from the iPhone’s top-right corner, open Control Center, tap Screen Mirroring, and choose the device name AirScreen displays.
This uses Apple’s native mirroring interface, but AirScreen needs to be opened on the Fire Stick each time. It’s described as free, with ads and limitations. I couldn’t verify the exact limits, so “free” isn’t enough information for me to declare a winner.
DoCast instead runs on iPhone or iPad and requires iOS 15 or later. Its listed Fire TV support includes Sticks, Cubes, and built-in Fire TV sets from Insignia, Toshiba, and Amazon. After connecting to the same Wi-Fi, open DoCast, select the Fire Stick, and follow any setup instructions.
Then tap Screen, adjust the mirroring settings if necessary, and tap Start mirroring.
That’s the full-screen option; Stop mirroring ends it. Videos, Photos, and Music are separate choices for selecting particular content instead.
I’d scrutinize the performance and payment claims before calling that smoother. Adjustable video quality and auto-rotation are listed features, while the claimed delay is less than one second on strong Wi-Fi. I haven’t measured that, and I couldn’t verify how much the recent updates improved Fire TV mirroring or media streaming. Photo casting is described as free and unlimited; screen mirroring and unlimited video and music streaming require Premium, with a one-time lifetime option. I’d check those DoCast payment details before assuming every button is included. Buttons are rarely the expensive part.
The additional case for it is iPhone-side control and support for Roku, Chromecast, and most smart TVs, potentially useful after replacing a TV or visiting a friend. I haven’t checked the wider DoCast compatibility against individual models, so I wouldn’t turn “most” into “mine.” Has anyone compared the actual delay and free-version restrictions of these two approaches on the same Fire Stick?