Wi-Fi Site Survey: Passive vs. Active

Should I use a passive or active site survey to track down a connection problem in our back office? I walked the room with my laptop and saw a steady signal at the desk where my calls keep cutting out. I didn’t have a call running during the walk.

A passive coverage check can show a steady signal without telling you whether your audio gets back to the access point on time. I’d use an active RF survey and start at the desk rather than walking the room again. Make a test call on your usual device when the office is busy, and watch the call stats for packet loss or jitter right when the audio cuts out.

Run an active survey at the problem desk and at a desk where calls work, using the same laptop on the same network. NetSpot is great for comparing upload speeds by location without changing anything on the router, including the encryption protocols.

Strong signal doesn’t rule out packet loss. I’d use NetSpot for an active RF (radio frequency) survey, but I wouldn’t judge the desk by upload speed. Make a test call there and, if your app shows call stats, watch for packet loss or jitter right when the audio cuts out. A speed test can average away the brief gaps you’re hearing.

Have you tried a call at that desk over Ethernet with Wi-Fi turned off? I’d do that before spending time on either survey.

Keep the laptop, headset, and call app the same. Borrow a cable if you can and try it when the problem usually shows up. The useful comparison here is wired versus wireless at the same desk, not your desk versus somebody else’s.

If the audio cuts out on Ethernet too, you’ve reproduced the problem without Wi-Fi. Set the survey aside. If calls keep breaking up on Wi-Fi but stay clear on the cable under similar conditions, go with an active survey at the desk. One quiet call either way doesn’t settle it.

Walking in with the laptop already connected can give you a different result than opening it at the desk. If your office has several access points under the same Wi-Fi name, the laptop may hang on to the one it picked down the hall. The name on the screen stays the same, so that’s easy to miss.

I’d go active, but I’d skip the room map. Next time a call breaks up, leave the Wi-Fi alone for a minute. Check which access point you’re actually using. The ID to look for in the connection details is the BSSID. Jot it down with the time. If those details aren’t visible on your laptop, that timestamp gives whoever runs the office Wi-Fi a specific call to check.

Once you’re off the call, disconnect and reconnect without leaving your chair. Check the ID again and try another call. If the laptop picks a different access point and the audio clears up, see whether that pattern repeats on your usual walk back to the desk. A single good call after a reconnect doesn’t tell you much. Repeated trouble on one ID and clear calls on another, from the same chair, gives IT something specific to chase.

The cable test is useful for a different reason. It takes Wi-Fi out of the picture, but it can’t tell you which access point the laptop chose on the way in. I’d save that detail before plugging in.